Communities Online

  • “Communities in Cyberspace”
  • The Hong Kongs, New Yorks and Tokyos of the Internet (NYT, 30 October 2007)

The “Communities in Cyberspace” reading reinforces my view that in general the human reactions are similar no matter what technology we are looking. Yes, there are nuances with each one of the applications, but in general we’re still dealing with the same issues of identity, honesty, regulation, quality of communication, etc. One possible explanation is that the technology hasn’t really changed that much (just looks better). For example, Kollock and Smith talk about “usenets” and “newsgroups”, which are not that different than blogs today. But by improving the speed, the range, and controls of online collaborations tools we are seeing a more robust development of these online communities. Though we should not forget, that “online” communities were present in the time of the Telegraph!

However, technology is allowing us to do more complex collaborations online, for which technology is mimicking more and more “real” life. In this process we will increasingly face the same issues online and offline. For example, the complexities and issues of establishing identity online may not be much different than offline. It is a bit of a misnomer that online worlds guard us from our racial, class and religious biases because we don’t see the person. There’s always a way for people to be prejudicial — if that’s their belief.

Online communities work best when there is a offline relationship to support it. Being online should not be used as a shield against who we are (other than for common sense security protection). Having a offline relationship makes online relationships (and collaboration) much more rich and just work better. Messages are much more significant when there’s a offline tie. For example, think of Twitter, how is a one line significant? Well if you have a real-life relationship a one line has a lot more context.

Finally, I agree with the reading on the sense that these technology are double-edged. My own experience with online communities ranges from great to very bad. On the bad end, I had a health scare and sought online communities for support and knowledge. I not only got freaked out from the amount of crazy advice from non-medical people, but I actually ended up putting my life at risk for believing some of it. On the other had, when my dad had cancer three doctors worked on his case from three different countries. That was amazing.

I cannot stop but wonder, what will happen once “virtual reality” is not that different from “reality”. I guess some french Philosophers have already mused about this quite a bit.

Questions to ponder upon:

1. How are online communities of the past (a.k.a. telegraph) different from today’s communities (i.e. Second Life, Blogs, etc.)?
2. What are the factors that make an online community work well?
3. How do you establish your identity online and how does it vary from technology to technology?

Blogged with Flock

Published by


Tech marketing executive. Latina who loves the rain. Proud mami of two amazing children.

One thought on “Communities Online”

  1. Hi Adri,

    I agree with you for the most part. I too think that online communities work best when there is a component of that group that exists in the real world. My class presentation was actually on the creation of local attachment based on meet-up groups online.

    I would like to answer your first question:
    I think that the main difference between online communities of the past and those of the present day, is that now you can find a community that matches many nuanced interests of your own, rather than the ‘one large room’ of the past telegraph, usenets and such. As time goes on the communities in which we inhabit both online and in the real world are becoming much more specialized.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s